10 Steps Involved in Structuring an Employee Stock Ownership Plan

Reading Time: 5 minutes

A Practical Guide for Business Owners Considering an ESOP

An Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) is not a single transaction, but rather a multi-step process that blends exit planning, corporate finance, tax strategy, and employee engagement and ownership.

When structured correctly, an ESOP can provide liquidity to owners and preserve company culture, while offering both significant tax advantages and a long-term succession solution for the seller. When structured poorly, on the other hand, it can strain cash flow and create governance challenges.

This article describes the ten – (10) steps to structuring an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP.)

Step 1: Determining Whether an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) Fits –

Not every company is an Employee Stock Ownership (ESOP) candidate. Before deciding on an ESOP, a business owner should assess:

Whether the business’ profitability and cash flow has been consistent;
The capability of the leadership team in the owner’s absence;
The predictability of the business’ revenue streams;
The business owner’s desire to keep the business independent; and
The business owner’s willingness to operate under ERISA rules and ongoing oversight.

Takeaway: An ESOP is most effective for companies that are stable, well-managed, and culturally aligned with employee ownership.

Step 2: Getting Clarity Around the Owner’s Exit Goals and Timeline –

ESOPs are highly flexible, but only when designed around clear objectives. Key questions for getting clarity around the business owner’s goals and exit timeline include:

Whether the goal is a partial ESOP or full liquidity transaction ?
If the owner wants to remain involved post-transaction ?
If the ESOP a near-term exit or a phased transition ? and
Whether legacy, tax efficiency, and/or employee retention are priorities ?

Takeaway: These answers will drive ownership percentage, transaction structure, and exit timing.

Step 3: Assembling the ESOP Advisory Team –

An ESOP requires specialized expertise. The ESOP advisory team typically includes:

Legal counsel with ESOP experience;
An independent valuation firm;
A trustee, who represents the employee’s interests;
An ESOP-savvy CPA or tax advisor;
An investment banker or financial advisor (for leveraged transactions;) and
A third-party ESOP administrator.

Takeaway: Assembling the ESOP Advisory Team ensures regulatory compliance, fair valuation, and financial sustainability.

Step 4: Conducting a Feasibility Study –

A feasibility study analyzes whether the company can support an ESOP transaction before committing.

This study evaluates things like:

Company valuation and purchase price range;
The cash flow available for debt service;
Impact on operations and growth capital;
Tax implications for the company and selling owner; and
Long-term repurchase obligations.

Takeaway: The outcome determines whether the ESOP is viable, and at what scale.

Step 5: Obtaining an Independent Business Valuation –

Federal law requires that ESOP shares be purchased at fair market value (FMV.) An independent valuation:

Establishes the purchase price;
Protects both employees and the selling owner; and
Serves as the foundation for the transaction.

Takeaway: This valuation is updated annually after the ESOP is formed.

Step 6: Designing the ESOP Structure:

This is where strategy meets mechanics. Key ESOP design decisions include:

The percentage (%) of ownership sold to the ESOP;
The percentage (%) of the leveraged vs. non-leveraged ESOP;
Voting vs. non-voting shares;
The allocation formula for employees;
The vesting schedule; and
The governance and control provisions.

Takeaway: The structure must balance liquidity, control, compliance, and long-term sustainability.

Step 7: Arranging for Financing (If The Exit Involves a Leveraged ESOP –)

Most ESOPs are leveraged, meaning the ESOP borrows money to purchase shares.

Common financing sources include:

Bank loans;
Seller notes;
Internal company financing; and
Combination structures.

Takeaway: Debt terms must align with realistic cash flow projections to avoid overburdening the business.

Step 8: Executing the Transaction –

Once structure and financing are finalized:

The ESOP trust is established;
Shares are sold to the ESOP;
Funds are distributed to the selling owner(s;) and
Debt repayment begins through company contributions.

Takeaway: At this point, the ESOP has become a shareholder of the company.

Step 9: Implementing Ongoing Administration and Governance –

An ESOP is not a “set it and forget it” transaction. Ongoing responsibilities include:

Annual valuations;
Compliance testing;
Trustee oversight;
Employee communications;
Repurchase obligation planning; and
Fiduciary governance.

Takeaway: Strong administration protects both the company and plan participants.

Step 10: Educating Employees and Building an Ownership Culture –

An ESOP works best when employees understand it. Best practices include:

Communicating how the ESOP works;
Tying ownership to performance;
Reinforcing long-term thinking; and
Building financial literacy among employees.

Takeaway: Without education, an ESOP is just a retirement plan; however, with it, it becomes a strategic advantage.

Final Thoughts

Structuring an ESOP is both a financial transaction and a long-term commitment.

When thoughtfully designed, an ESOP can:

Provide liquidity without selling to a third party;
Preserve company culture and independence;
Deliver powerful tax benefits; and
Align employees with long-term success.

The key is approaching the process with clear goals, the right advisors, and a long-term mindset.

Did you like the content in this article ? For more information about business exit and succession planning, the author has posted his entire series of business exit and succession planning articles on the media page of his website at www.greaterprairiebusinessconsulting.com.

About the Author:

James J. Talerico, Jr. is an award-winning author, blogger, speaker, and nationally recognized small to mid-sized (SMB) business expert.

With more than thirty- (30) years of diversified business experience, Jim has a solid track record and an A+ BBB rating helping thousands of business owners across the US and in Canada tackle tough business problems to improve the performance of their organizations.

His client success stories have been highlighted in the Wall St. Journal, Dallas Business Journal, Chicago Daily Herald, and on MSNBC’s Your Business. He was named “Texas Business Consulting CEO of the Year,” by CEO Today Magazine, identified as a “Top 10 Management Consulting Entrepreneur to Watch” by Entrepreneur Magazine, was listed among the “10 Most Visionary Companies to Watch” by The Inc. Magazine, and has also been ranked among the “Top Small Business Consultants” followed on Twitter.

For more than half a decade, Jim was a regular guest on “The Price of Business,” a nationally syndicated radio program on Bloomberg Talk Radio and has also appeared as a subject matter expert on many FOX Radio interviews. He is a regular contributor to several blog sites and has frequently been quoted in publications like the New York Times, Dallas Morning News, Philadelphia Inquirer, The Entrepreneur’s Review, The International Exit Planning Association’s blog site, and on INC.com, in addition to numerous, other industry publications, radio broadcasts, business books, and Internet media.

Jim received a Gold “Stevie Award” for “Thought Leader of the Year,” a Gold “Stevie Award” for “Media Hero of the Year During Covid” and a Bronze “Stevie Award” for “Best Entrepreneur” in the Category of “Business and Professional Services” at the American Business Awards® in New York City. The competition received more than 3,700 nominations and is the premier accolade for business excellence in the US honoring organizations of all sizes and industries. Jim also received an “Outstanding Leadership Award” at the Money 2.0 Conference for his contributions to the financial services industry.

Jim is the author of “8 Steps to Becoming an ETHICS FOCUSED ORGANIZATION,™” a small business certification program that utilizes a unique eight – (8) step approach for strengthening ethics in any organization. The certification program won the Better Business Bureau’s “Torch Award for Ethics” for the North – Central Texas Region, the International Better Business Bureau’s “ Torch Award for Ethics,” and a Gold “Stevie Award” for “Ethics in Sales” at the International Sales & Customer Service Stevie Awards®. Participants who complete this certification program are eligible to receive eight – (8) continuing education units from the University of Texas’ Division of Enterprise Development.

Jim received his Certified Business Exit Consultant (CBEC)® designation from The International Exit Planning Association (IEPA) to help entrepreneurs, small business owners, family businesses, and middle market companies maximize their business exit, and he received his certification in succession planning from the ASPE. Jim currently Co-Chairs The International Exit Planning Association’s Education Committee.

Jim is also a Certified Management Consultant (CMC)® and has been an active member of the Institute of Management Consultants. The Certified Management Consultant® mark is awarded by the Institute of Management Consultants USA (IMC USA) and represents evidence of the highest standards of consulting, a commitment to continuous development, and an adherence to the ethical canons of the profession. Less than 1% of all consultants in the world are Certified Management Consultants (CMC.)®