The AI Debate
My final article in the Life as an (Independent) Author will tackle the AI debate. First, I want to make is clear I have not used AI for my writing. However, the companies I use for trailers, covers and marketing have used AI generated images. On to the debate…
Trolls in the Hood!
Trolls recently dropped comments on one of my Canthany Rising Meta ads. Normally, I ignore them, but these challenged my Christianity directly over the use of AI in the book cover. Here are the main comments:
Wow, a “Christian” novel using AI slop. What happened to “thou shalt not steal”?
You obviously used AI for your cover. How can I trust you didn’t use AI for the book?
I did attempt to reason with these people, but the first was really just a troll. (As everyone knows, you “don’t feel the Trolls!” Oops.) The second was an art student. I think this person really wanted me to prove to her I didn’t use AI for my writing, but she didn’t buy any of my reasoning. So, I’m going to explain fully, for you, what I couldn’t do on socials. The arguments are I’m stealing and I’m guilty by association.
Stealing
When the stealing accusation came up, I did go down the rabbit hole a little with the trolls. There are two trains of thought with regard to “stealing.” One revolves around Anthropic’s (and other AI companies) use of other people’s Intellectual Property (IP) to train their Large Language Models (LLMs). The other states I’m stealing from artists, but they didn’t elaborate how. I’m taking the approach that the money I spend on a book cover is going to someone other than an artist, therefore I’m “stealing” from the artist.
Anthropic
There is no doubt Anthropic pulled some of their data from public domain sources and some from less-than-ethical sources. The civil lawsuit in the headlines proves that. As of this writing, Anthropic has not been told they need to delete the less-than-ethical sources and the DOJ’s opinion is that what they did is considered “Fair Use.” (It isn’t, but that’s my opinion on it.)
Using AI for images can be a form of stealing if you know the images infringe on someone else’s IP. This is where things can get murky. I’ve used MidJourney to play around with character image concepts. There have been times the images generated showed remnants of the artist’s signature. I deleted those immediately and any close in style and tone to it.
My trailer for Canthany Rising also had such an issue. An early version had the bear character morph from a half-polar-half-panda part way through a scene into an easily recognizable animated martial-art panda from a top 3 animation studio. I was not happy with the company for letting an obvious violation make it through their quality controls and they had to fix it.
As a Christian, I have to be very careful of what I can use. My book trailers are assembled (not going to use the word “created”) by a company which uses AI along with a team of skilled professionals to put it all together. My book covers are assembled by a company which uses AI for many of the images, but a human still has to stitch them together along with all the typesetting. Some of my marketing banners and posts are put together by a freelancer which also uses some AI images. I scrutinize every frame for potential violations. If I don’t see anything glaring, my conscience is clear.
I’m “Stealing” from the Artist
No, I’m not.
Writing is a business. I have expenses. I’m making a business decision to keep expenses down by paying a company to assemble a trailer, book cover, and/or marketing materials. Those that use AI are generally less expensive than freelance artists.
There are those which will still complain that I should be paying human artists. Keep the artists in business. So, the argument is now to not let technology displace a human’s craft. Technology has been displacing workers for generations. Farmers and farm hands first with farming machines. Auto workers were laid off permanently as robots entered the assembly lines. How many other human jobs have been replaced by technology? Many. Artists (images and writing) have thought technology could never replace them.
Sorry. Technology caught up.
Would I prefer to have a human design my covers? Sure. I checked into artists from my writing groups and Fiverr. The artists that I thought could do my books justice were either 6-8 months out, terribly expensive, or both. The artists which were more in my price range looked like comic books or anime, not a book cover. When I looked into some of the cover companies, I found one I liked and covers looked fantastic. It became a business decision.
Guilt by Association
As I mentioned before, I don’t use AI to write my stories. There may be AI used behind the scenes for spellchecking. I hired a human editor for the developmental and line edits. There is AI behind a tool I use to proofread my final version, but I see this as no different than spellcheck. It’s just using the Chicago Manual of Style as the basis.
I’m not going to flat out dismiss the argument of “AI for one, AI for all,” because there are people doing exactly this. However, this argument has me shaking my head. The argument is both images and writing are both “art,” therefore since I allowed AI for images, I used AI for writing. The “art” umbrella isn’t applicable.
This is the same as saying if a person paints masterpieces, that person must also write best-selling fiction because they are both “art.” Um, no. Apples and oranges folks…which, by the way, are both “fruits.” A person may be brilliant as a painter and horrible at writing and vice versa. (I’m in the “vice versa” bucket, but without the best sellers.) Images and writing are two different processes and AI handles them differently.
I looked up a few things about AI writing (ironically, using Microsoft’s AI). There is a Story.com article which explains the step-by-step process for writing using AI. One of the main points it makes is that you need to heavily edit the output “to add voice, pacing, and emotional depth.” Those are critical to any story written. Without those, you get what the AI haters call “AI slop.” The story will have no soul.
Conclusion
AI art and writing are not going anywhere.
I won’t use it to write my stories because it wouldn’t have my style, humor or imagination. Technology hasn’t progressed enough, but I suspect it’s coming.
I’ve made the conscious decision to use/allow AI for images on my site and for marketing. I will be using human artists for character art as I can afford it. Because some of the material the LLMs have acquired is less-than-ethical, I will be vigilant to remove anything which may infringe on someone else’s IP.
And there you have it. My take on AI and the last of my articles. I hope you enjoyed them and I hope you’ll join my worlds, where Christian values, psionics and the supernatural meet!
Want to follow my journey and read my blog? Sign up on https://www.kebauthor.com
My books on Amazon:
Canthany Rising: https://www.amazon.com/Canthany-Rising-Christian-LitRPG-Adventure-ebook/dp/B0GZ598XPX
The Accident: https://www.amazon.com/Accident-Story-Faith-Psionics-Supernatural-ebook/dp/B0FSH7NPPF
The Prodigy and the Telepath: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HGKNM19N
Kenneth Bliss writes Christian science fiction and Christian LitRPG fantasy featuring spiritual warfare, battles reminiscent of TTRPG encounters, and heroes whose faith shapes the outcome of impossible conflicts. As an unabashed nerd, he has read hundreds of sci-fi/fantasy books and played TTRPG and MMORPG games for decades. He turned his sights to the written word to express his love of God, sci-fi/fantasy, and psionics. He lives near a small town in Michigan with his two cats.
Author website link: https://www.kebauthor.com
Amazon link Canthany Rising: https://www.amazon.com/Canthany-Rising-Christian-LitRPG-Adventure-ebook/dp/B0GZ598XPX
Amazon link The Accident: https://www.amazon.com/Accident-Story-Faith-Psionics-Supernatural-ebook/dp/B0FSH7NPPF



